 |
 |

|
By Tim Cool
If you're a pastor, facilities manager, or other church staff, here's what you need to know to start saving money on the operation and maintenance of your facility.
The following are facts tied to facilities management, cost of ownership, and cost of operation associated with ministry facilities. What are the direct and indirect costs? How does on-site staffing compare to outsourcing? How much should be allocated for facilities management in a church budget? What kind of capital reserve account should be established? How do life cycle costs impact budgeting?
The International Facilities Management Association (IFMA) is the world's largest and most widely recognized international association for professional facility managers. Every year, IFMA produces a research report entitled "Operations and Maintenance Benchmarks." The recent report presented some very interesting statistics.
#1: CURRENT REPLACEMENT VALUE (CRV)
 |
| Tim Cool, president and chief solutions officer, Cool Solutions Group, Charlotte, NC |
The CRV index represents the level of funding provided for maintaining an organization's capital assets. This percentage is derived by dividing total annual maintenance by current replacement value converted to a percentage. The National Research Council recommends a budget allocation for routine maintenance and repair to be in the 2%-4% range of the aggregate CRV.
According to the IFMA report, the 2008 average CRV Index was 1.55% for all the respondents, which is down from previous years.
#2: MAINTENANCE COSTS
The IFMA report breaks down this analysis into subsections that allow church staff to do some comparisons.
- Gegraphical Region: The Maintenance Cost ranged from $1.75/square foot to $2.68/square foot.
- Facilities Use: "Religious Facility" use represented about .8% of the respondents. The factor for these facilities was $1.78/square foot. Compared to other facilities, this "feels" low.
- Mean: The mean of the respondents was $2.22/square foot.
- Age: Facilities between the age of 5 and 50 years old averaged $2.40/square foot. Of these costs, 42% was for preventive maintenance.
# 3: COST OF UTILITIES
When looking at operating budgets and the cost to keep facilities functioning at peak performance, one must look at utilities. Two of the report's findings are telling here:
- Mean: The mean is $2.56/square foot.
- Facilities Use: For the "religious" facilities, the factor is only $1.65. This may be high as other sources show about $1.25/square foot.
#4: JANITORIAL
This is an area of facilities management in which there is often the greatest fluctuation and the most turnover in staff/vendors.
- Mean: $1.55/square foot.
- Facilities Use: Only .4% of the respondents indicated their facilities were for "religious use." This subset reported a factor of $1.48/square foot.
# 5: COST OF OPERATION
Now it's time to look at the total cost factor.
- Facilities Use: The religious facilities factor in the report is $5.17/square foot.
- Mean: $6.54/square foot. However, buildings 5-50 years old jumped to $7.05/square foot.
- Cost: Distributed as follows:
- Maintenance: 35%
- Janitorial: 27%
- Utilities: 38%
#6: GREEN/SUSTAINABLE FACILITIES ARE NOT A FAD
Green, sustainable and LEED are terms that are becoming commonplace to most people who are associated with the development and maintenance of any facility. The idea behind these movements makes good business sensenot just to take care of the planet God has entrusted to us, but also to reduce operating costs and, in most cases, a great deal of cost.
# 7: PEOPLE COST MONEY
Plain and simple, a church staff costs money. Some of it is direct costs that one can see, touch and even budget. Others are indirect and, as such, generally cannot be tracked or determined if the person or time being given to a task is effective or efficient.
#8: PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE IS LESS EXPENSIVE THAN CORRECTIVE REPAIRS
It is the experience of facilities management provider Cool Solutions Group, Charlotte, N.C., that preventive maintenance, when done correctly, can cost less than 50% of the cost of corrective maintenance when calculated over a 3-5 year period of time.
CONCLUSIONS:
- To keep pace with the deterioration of facilities, church staff should be looking at a 1.55%-2% budget based on the Current Replacement Value (CRV).
- $2.00/square foot is a reasonable amount to budget for maintenance and repairs.
- $1.25/square foot is a reasonable amount to budget for utility costs.
- $1.50/square foot may be a reasonable benchmark for janitorial services, but an individual church's own experiences may be a better judge.
- While $5.50/square foot appears to be a reasonable number for total operational costs, a budget of approximately $4.75/square foot may be ample.
- "Green" is far more than being ecologically prudent, it is about reducing costs in the immediate and long term.
- People cost money, so church staff is advised to re-look at the direct and indirect costs and understand how they impact budget, staff, and ministry opportunities.
- Preventive maintenance, rather than corrective repairs, is a far better approach to caring for the resources God has entrusted to us. These are real dollarsbe good stewards of these dollars and resources.
To view a White Paper that serves as the basis for these conclusions, please download at http://coolsolutionsgroup.com/resources?did=11.
Tim Cool is president and chief solutions officer (CSO) of Cool Solutions Group, Charlotte, N.C. The company's primary area of service is Facilities Management for ministry facilities. Cool is a member of IFMA, NACBA, NACFM and Elevation Church. He can be reached at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address), Twitter@TLCool, or on the web at www.coolsolutionsgroup.com. He will also be available at WFX Charlotte, Booth #1205, Oct. 28-30.
www.coolsolutionsgroup.com
|
 |
|
 |
|
St. Thomas Korean Catholic Center, Anaheim, Calif.
Real estate and construction services firm Optym, an Irvine, Calif.-based Snyder Langston special projects division focused on quality small-scale revitalization and new construction, has completed construction on a 16,000-square-foot sanctuary at St. Thomas Korean Catholic Center in Anaheim, Calif. for the Orange County Diocese. The building features an open roof wood structure with sizable chandelier light features, as well as a large rustic alter with a baptismal. The exterior includes unique tile and masonry features, a spiral sheet metal roof, and a majestic steeple that reaches 80 feet into the air. HMC Architects of Irvine, Calif., was the architect of record, and Newport, Calif.'s Abacus Project Management Inc. was the construction manager. |
| |
Worship Facilities Magazine, Church Production Magazine, and WFX -- Worship Facilities Conference & Expo are divisions of Production Media Inc., 2610 Wycliff Road, Suite 405, Raleigh, NC 27607.
Carol Badaracco Padgett, Editor
Chris Pernell, Associate Publisher
Visit www.pmipub.com for more information.
Copyright (c) 2009 Production Media, Inc.
|
|
Lutron Offers New Lighting Energy Audit for Facilities
Lutron Services Co. of Coopersburg, Pa., announces the introduction of the Lighting Energy Audit, a new program designed to help facility managers and building owners reduce lighting-associated costs, implement creative energy-saving strategies, and enhance their reputation as leaders in environmentally responsible initiatives.
As commercial buildings and churches across the United States continue to age, facility management teams are increasingly faced with issues ranging from inefficient light sources to outdated control strategies. The growing focus on sustainability has prompted many of these teams to re-examine their lighting systems and look for new ways to save energy while lowering operating and maintenance costs.
"A 2008 Department of Energy study indicated that lighting uses 38% of the electricity in commercial buildings," says Glen Kruse, director of Lutron¹s Commercial Solutions and Services, "and wasted energy means wasted money." Although replacing older fixtures and lamps is often a quick fix, the Lutron Lighting Energy Audit seeks to go beyond the light sources by providing a complete analysis of lighting control strategies currently in use, opportunities for improvement, and recommendations for cost-effective solutions.
An audit includes an onsite visit and facility evaluation, interviews with facility stakeholders to understand how the building is used, and a complete performance analysis to determine the most appropriate solutions.
Suggestions may range from installing wireless occupancy sensors to reprogramming existing lighting control systems or updating timeclock schedules. The final result is a customized solution for each facility.
To learn more, visit www.lutron.com/LightingAudit.
Videx to Present CyberLock Access Control Class at WFX
 |
Church staff and facilities managers are invited to attend a CyberLock access and key control class at WFX Charlotte on Oct. 30thpresented by manufacturer Videx.
|
Videx of Corvallis, Ore., will present a class on CyberLock access and key control at WFX at the Charlotte Convention Center in Charlotte, N.C., on Friday, Oct. 30, from 1:30-2:30 p.m. For churches that are tired of re-keying their facilities, the 60-minute class will discuss how electronic locks and keys can provide an affordable way to take control of keys and stop re-keying expenses.
The CyberLock system will also be displayed in Videx's booth, #1824, on the WFX expo floor. For more information, see www.cyberlock.com or visit www.wfxweb.com.
 |
A free catalog of emergency lighting and exit signs, as well as architectural white LED solid state luminaries, is now available from LightGuard.
|
LightGuard Releases Complimentary Catalog of Facility Emergency Lighting Products
LightGuard of Burgaw, N.C., offers a new full-color product catalog that demonstrates the company's continued commitment to providing life safety products to the church market. The catalog details LightGuard's line of emergency lighting and exit signs designed to meet facility life-safety needs.
The catalog also contains some of the company's newest architectural white LED solid state luminaries that serve as security and emergency lighting, such as Unity, Grafix and Illusion III. The catalog is divided into 10 sections for easy access to each product grouping.
Free catalogs are available at www.lightguard.com.
LampRecycling.com Offers Facilities Managers a New Resource
 |
At LampRecycling.com, facilities managers can set up a program that provides containers to help easily recycle items such as bulbs, batteries and electronic waste. The program also generates online-accessible tracking reports of total waste recycled. (Click thumbnail for full-size image)
|
Air Cycle Corp. of Broadview, Ill., announces the upgrade of LampRecycling.com, an online resource for facilities managers and personnel needing a simple, cost-effective way to recycle fluorescent bulbs, CFLs, batteries, ballasts, and electronic waste. Through LampRecycling.com, users can set up a personal EasyPak Sustainable Recycling Program. The program allows users to order EasyPak recycling containers for multiple types of universal waste and return them via pre-paid FedEx. Once the waste is received for recycling, a recurring order is triggered and a new EasyPak container is shipped out automatically. The program's hands-off approach helps users save time and energy by not having to constantly search for and reorder new recycling solutions.
LampRecycling.com also offers additional features that can help facilities better understand and track recycling efforts. Once a user ships out a full EasyPak container, they can login to LampRecycling.com to view recycling reports that give totals of all waste they have recycled. These reports are accessible at any time and serve as a resource for marketing environmental progress to church members and the community.
For more information, visit www.LampRecycling.com.
Should Your Annual Budget Include Replacement Reserves?
By William I. Scrivens
 |
William I. Scrivens, reserve specialist, Miller Dodson Associates Inc., Annapolis, MD
|
You're probably sitting at a desk right now looking through this newsletter and considering which stories are worth further scrutiny.
From an annual budgeting point of view, several obvious things are occurring while you sip your coffee. And perhaps one thing is happening that's not so obvious.
Starting with the obvious, take a moment and look around; lights are probably on; the heating and air conditioning system is humming along; you're sitting in a chair at a desk; and the coffee pot is warm.
Annual budgets have operating expenses, and for the few items mentioned above there is the electrical bill and coffee, but also your compensation and insurance. This same budget also has a maintenance leg, which likely includes the service plan for the heating and air conditioning system.
Now for the less obvious ... will the heating and air conditioning system last forever; how about the coffee pot, or the lights and furnishings? All of these items have useful lives, and while you have been reading this newsletter, you have used a portion of these lives.
Admittedly, these are very small portions, but over the years they add up. Eventually because things wear out, they need to be replaced. But, where does this money come from? If it's a big-ticket item like the heating and air conditioning system or the roof or parking lot repaving, do you cut back on other services? Do you reduce your missionary work? Do you go to the congregation for a special collection or fundraising?
There is a better way. That is to include a Replacement Reserve Fund in your annual budget. Developed for community associations over the past several decades, this is a well established practice which is easily adaptable to your church or private school.
Paying for the electricity as you use it makes sense. Why not save for the replacement of the heating and air conditioning system while you use it, rather than scrambling to find the funds when it fails to keep you comfortable?
A properly prepared Replacement Reserve Study models all of the components in your facility with a replacement cost and remaining life. A Reserve Study then provides an annual budgeting recommendation so that when replacements are needed, the funds are available.
Keeping in mind that these documents are specific for community associations, more information on Replacement Reserve Studies can be found at Community Associations Institute, http://www.caionline.org.
William I. Scrivens is a reserve specialist at Miller Dodson Associates Inc, capital reserve consultants in Annapolis, Md. For more information on Miller Dodson, visit www.mdareserves.com.
GE Announces First Phased Array Corrosion Inspection Solution
The new Phasor CV/DM from GE Sensing & Inspection Technologies is the first phased array inspection device for corrosion spot identification in the marketplace. Corrosion spots are small, isolated areas where corrosion has reduced a pipe's wall thickness and can compromise its ability to safely hold pressure and its contents.
Part of GE's field-proven phased array family, the Phasor CV/DM reportedly provides extensive inspection coverage with each scan, identifying, measuring and evaluating even the smallest corrosion pit. The Phasor CV/DM has application in the oil and gas process, aerospace, power generation and general engineering sectors.
www.geinspectiontechnologies.com/en/index.html
Special-Lite Announces Availability of New Adjustable Continuous Hinge
The new Special-Lite SL-120 Continuous Hinge provides a simple, easy-to-install solution to compensate for out-of-plumb jambs in both new construction and door replacement. The SL-120 compensates for when rough openings or existing framing are not perfectly square. With adjustability of up to 1/8-inch in either direction or opposite directions top to bottom, the hinge allows Special-Lite flush doors to hang properly in less than perfect openings.
The durable Special-Lite hinges are covered by the same 10-year warranty as Special-Lite doors. The hinge is available with standard Class 1 anodized finishes in clear and dark bronze, with optional colors available.
www.special-lite.com/techdata/sales.htm
Cozy Products Cut Costs and Promote Safety
Heat promotes productivity and ends complaints at work from shivering staffin cold climates and in air-conditioned offices. However, companies end up paying large heating bills, and high costs drag down profits. Cozy products use only 90-150 watts, vs. the 1,500 watts drawn by a space heater, saving money and lowering the risk of potential fires.
Products include Cozy Legs, Toasty Toes, and the Ice-Away Snow Melt mat.
www.cozy-products.com
Crestron Mobile Pro iPhone Application Now Available
Now available for download from the iTunes App Store, Crestron Mobile Pro combines the capabilities of Crestron Mobileto view home or office alarm status and adjust lights and room temperatureswith greater power and flexibility for whole house control, including pre-set audio and lighting scenes, home entertainment and more. Both are compatible with the original iPhone, iPhone 3G and iPod touch.
With Crestron Mobile Pro, users simply tap the screen to select movies, music and TV in any room or adjust volume, light levels and room temperature with a touch. Using the Wi-Fi network locally or the powerful 3G and EDGE networks remotely, total control is at users' fingertips.
www.crestron.com
|
|